Why Your Business Phone Won’t Stop Ringing (And How to Fix It)

Google My Business calls are critical for local businesses—88% of consumers who search for a local business on their phone either call or visit within 24 hours. But there’s a problem: not all calls claiming to be from Google are legitimate. Here’s what you need to know:

Quick Answer: How to Identify Google My Business Spam Calls

• Real Google calls verify business info, never ask for payment, and come at your request
• Scam calls threaten urgent listing suspensions, demand money for rankings, or use vague company names like “Business Help Center”
• Take action immediately: Hang up, don’t press buttons, and report to the FTC and Google
• Protect yourself: Register with the National Do Not Call Registry and block suspicious numbers

The reality is frustrating. Your phone rings constantly with robocalls claiming your Google Business Profile will be suspended unless you pay immediately. Meanwhile, you’re trying to run a business and answer real customer calls that actually drive revenue.

The good news? Real Google calls exist—they help update your business hours, confirm service availability, or schedule appointments for customers. But scammers have learned to mimic these legitimate communications, making it harder than ever to tell the difference.

Phone calls from your Google Business Profile represent your highest-converting leads. Mobile searches result in phone calls 61% of the time, and these calls generate revenue 10-15 times more than web leads. That’s why scammers target this channel—they know business owners can’t afford to miss legitimate calls.

I’m Ronnie Katz, and I’ve been helping businesses optimize their Google My Business calls and online visibility since 2006. Through BullsEye Internet Marketing, I’ve worked with countless business owners who’ve been targeted by these exact scams, and I’ve developed proven strategies to stop spam while maximizing legitimate Google My Business calls that drive real revenue.

Google My Business calls word roundup:

• local pay per call
• pay per call services
• pay per call campaigns

Identifying the Threat: Is That Really Google Calling?

As business owners in Florida and across the United States, we receive countless calls daily. This section will help us distinguish between legitimate communications from Google and fraudulent scams targeting our businesses. It’s crucial to understand the difference, as making the wrong judgment can lead to missed opportunities or, worse, falling victim to a scam.

Red Flags of a Scam Call

Scammers are cunning. They often use tactics designed to create panic or urgency, hoping we’ll act without thinking. Here are the tell-tale signs that a call claiming to be from Google is, in fact, a scam:

• Urgent Threats: Does the caller claim there’s an “urgent issue” with your Google Business Profile or that it will be “suspended” or “deleted” if you don’t act immediately? Legitimate Google communication about your profile is rarely, if ever, urgent. In fact, Google’s communication regarding business profiles is often described as “glacially, insultingly, pathetically, painfully slow.” They will never contact you with urgent issues regarding your Google Business Profile.
• Demands for Payment: This is perhaps the biggest red flag. Google will never ask for payment information over the phone, especially not for your Google Business Profile to remain active or to improve its ranking. If a caller asks for money, hang up.
• Guaranteed Rankings: Be wary of anyone promising “top placement” or “guaranteed first-page rankings” on Google for a fee. As experts in digital marketing, we know there’s no way anyone can guarantee such results just by sending them money. Google explicitly states they will not guarantee special placement in their products.
• Vague Company Names: Scammers often use generic or misleading names like “Business Help Center” or “Google Listing Department.” If the caller is cagey about their specific company name or claims to “work with Google” rather than “for Google,” it’s a huge warning sign. Legitimate Google representatives will clearly identify themselves and the company they represent.
• Asking for Sensitive Info: Google will never ask you for sensitive personal or payment information over an unsolicited phone call. Never provide your bank details, credit card numbers, or login credentials to an unverified caller.
• Spoofed Phone Numbers: Scammers frequently “spoof” phone numbers to make them appear local or from a legitimate source. You might see a familiar area code, but this doesn’t mean the call is genuine. If you “Google” (haha) the phone number, you might find reports of it being associated with scams.
• Robotic Voices: Many of these calls are automated robocalls that mimic Google’s voice. While Google does make automated calls, scam robocalls often sound generic and follow a script that pushes you to “press 1” for an “expert.”
• Lack of Personalization: Scam calls are typically generic. They won’t refer to your business by name or demonstrate specific knowledge of your Google Business Profile.

Green Flags of a Legitimate Google Call

Now that we know what to watch out for, let’s understand what a genuine call from Google looks like. These calls are far less common than the scam attempts, but they do happen:

• Verifying Business Info: Google may place automated calls to confirm or update your business hours, check service availability (e.g., “Are you open for dine-in?”), or confirm product availability. These calls are designed to keep your Google Business Profile accurate for customers.
• No Sales Pitch: Legitimate automated calls from Google are not unsolicited sales calls. They are for information gathering or service facilitation (like scheduling an appointment for a customer), not to sell you anything.
• Caller Identifies as Google Employee: If a live operator calls, they will clearly identify themselves as a Google employee. They will not be evasive or claim to be an “SEO specialist working with Google.”
• Call Is at Your Request: Google will typically only call your business if you have initiated contact with them, perhaps through a support request on business.google.com, or if you’ve requested a verification call. You can learn more about how Google helps protect against fraudulent calls by visiting their official support page: Help protect against fraudulent calls.
• Caller Provides a Verifiable @google.com Email: A legitimate Google representative will always have an email address ending in @google.com or @xwf.google.com. If they offer to send you an email, check the domain carefully. They will also be able to tell you their location, such as Atlanta or Boulder, where Google has offices.

Your Action Plan: How to Stop and Report Spam Calls

Dealing with persistent scam calls can be incredibly frustrating. The good news is that we’re not powerless. By taking a few immediate steps and knowing how to report these nuisances, we can reduce unwanted calls and help authorities track down scammers.

Immediate Actions to Take During a Suspicious Call

When your phone rings and it smells like a scam, rapid, decisive action is key:

• Hang Up Immediately: Do not try to argue, reason, or engage with the caller. The moment you suspect it’s a scam, just hang up. Your time is valuable, and these callers thrive on any interaction.
• Do Not Press Any Buttons: If it’s an automated call prompting you to “press 1 to speak to an agent” or “press 9 to be removed from our list,” do not press any buttons. Pressing a button often signals to scammers that your number is active and you’re willing to engage, potentially leading to even more unwanted calls.
• Do Not Provide Information: Never, ever give out personal, financial, or business-sensitive information to an unsolicited caller. This includes your name, address, phone number, email, Social Security number, bank details, or Google Business Profile login credentials.
• Do Not Engage with the Caller: As tempting as it might be to tell them off, engaging with scammers can sometimes make things worse. They might record your voice, glean information from your tone, or simply mark you as a responsive target. A quick hang-up is the best defense.

Reporting Scams and Reducing Future Calls

Taking immediate action is crucial, but reporting these calls is how we collectively fight back against scammers. Here’s how to do it:

• Report to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC): The FTC is a primary agency for combating fraud. You can file a complaint with them, which helps them track patterns and take legal action against fraudulent companies. Visit their website at www.donotcall.gov or call 1-888-382-1222.
• File a Complaint with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC): For issues specifically related to phone calls, the FCC is another important resource. They handle complaints about unwanted calls, including robocalls and telemarketing. You can File a complaint with the FCC online or by calling 1-888-CALL-FCC (1-888-225-5322).
• Register with the National Do Not Call Registry: While scammers often ignore this, registering your business phone number on the National Do Not Call Registry can help reduce legitimate telemarketing calls. It’s illegal for telemarketers to call numbers on this list. For US numbers, you can register at www.donotcall.gov/register/reg.aspx or call 1-888-382-1222.
• Notify Google of the Scam: Google is actively working to combat these scams and has taken legal action against many perpetrators. You can help them by reporting suspicious calls directly. Visit Google’s specific form to notify Google of third-party violations. Include details like the caller’s company name, contact info, any emails or documentation received, and specific call details.
• Block Problematic Numbers: Ask your phone company if they can block calls from any problematic numbers. Many mobile carriers and even some VoIP providers offer services to block or filter unwanted calls.

Understanding Legitimate Google My Business Calls

Once we’ve mastered the art of fending off scammers, it’s equally important to understand the types of valid calls we might receive from Google. This section explains these communications so we don’t accidentally block a helpful interaction that could benefit our business.

Automated Calls for Profile Updates

Google uses automated calls to keep your business information current and to facilitate customer requests. These calls are a service to both businesses and consumers, ensuring accurate information on Google Search and Maps.

• Confirming Business Hours: Google may call to verify your current operating hours, especially around holidays or if they detect a discrepancy. For example, if you’re a restaurant in Miami, Google might call to confirm your holiday hours before displaying them to potential diners.
• Checking Service Availability: For service-based businesses like a spa in Fort Lauderdale, Google might call to confirm if you offer a particular service or if you have availability for walk-ins.
• Appointment Scheduling: If a customer uses Google Search or Maps to book an appointment (e.g., for a hair salon in Palm Beach), Google might place an automated call to your business to confirm the details.
• Inventory Checks: For businesses with physical products, Google might call to confirm the price and availability of specific items requested by a customer. This is less common if you use Google Merchant Center to share in-store product details.

These automated calls are monitored and recorded for quality assurance. Google also tries to limit the number of calls and avoids calling late at night or early in the morning to minimize disruption.

How to opt-out: While these calls are generally helpful, you do have the option to opt out. You can tell Google over the phone during an automated call (e.g., “Please remove my business from your list.”). Alternatively, you can change your Business Profile settings:

1. Go to your Business Profile (you must be verified).
2. Select “More” (often represented by a three-dot menu).
3. Choose “Business Profile settings.”
4. Steer to “Advanced settings.”
5. Under “Google automated calls and text messages,” you can turn these features on or off.

For more details on these automated interactions, refer to About automated calls from Google.

Manual Calls from Google Representatives

Beyond automated calls, you might occasionally receive a direct call from a live Google representative. These are typically in response to an action you’ve taken or for specific support needs:

• Verification Calls: When you set up or make significant changes to your Google Business Profile, Google might call to verify your business’s legitimacy. This is a crucial step in maintaining control over your listing.
• Google Ads Support: If you’re running Google Ads campaigns, a Google Ads specialist might call to discuss your account performance, offer optimization tips, or provide support. These calls are usually scheduled or follow up on a support request you initiated.
• Google Maps Support: For complex issues related to your business’s appearance on Google Maps, a support agent might call to help resolve the problem.
• Customer Service Follow-ups: If you’ve contacted Google support for any reason, a representative might call you back to follow up on your inquiry or ensure your issue has been resolved.

In all these cases, a legitimate Google representative will identify themselves, confirm they are calling from Google, and will not ask for payment or sensitive information. They will also be calling in response to a direct action or request from you or your business.

Beyond Spam: Optimizing Your Profile for Quality Calls

Once we’ve curbed the spam, our focus can shift to what truly matters: attracting high-intent customers through legitimate Google My Business calls. These are the calls that lead to conversions, appointments, and sales for our businesses in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and across Florida.

The Recent Shift in Google’s Call Tracking

Historically, Google Business Profiles offered a “Calls” tab within Insights, providing basic data on phone calls originating from your listing. However, there’s been a significant change that impacts how we track these valuable leads:

• Discontinuation of Call History: Google has announced that as of July 31, 2024, call history reports will disappear from Google Business Profiles. This means the native ‘Calls’ tab, which used to store call records for 45 days, is no longer available. While your profile will still receive calls and track other metrics like web visits and directions, specific call data will no longer be available directly within your Business Profile. For businesses that relied on this, it’s a major shift.
• Why Native Insights Are Limited: Even before this change, Google’s native call tracking had significant limitations. Google’s Insights only recorded mobile click-to-call actions, meaning desktop calls—where a user manually dials your number after seeing it on their screen—didn’t appear in the data at all. This led to an incomplete picture of actual call volume. Furthermore, the system could sometimes inflate numbers by counting dropped calls.
• The New Importance of Third-Party Tools: With Google discontinuing its native call history features, third-party call tracking solutions have become more critical than ever. These tools fill the gap, offering comprehensive insights that Google’s platform no longer provides. They are now essential for understanding the true impact of your Google Business Profile on phone leads.

Best Practices for Managing Your Google My Business Calls

To thrive in this new landscape and ensure your Google My Business calls are driving maximum ROI, we need to adopt a more sophisticated approach:

• Using Tracking Numbers Correctly: This is the cornerstone of effective call tracking. Instead of your main business number, use unique, dedicated tracking numbers on your Google Business Profile. These numbers forward calls to your main line but allow you to identify which calls originated from your Google listing. This provides invaluable data for attribution.
• Maintaining NAP Consistency: “NAP” stands for Name, Address, and Phone Number. It’s crucial for local SEO that your NAP details are consistent across all online directories, including your Google Business Profile. When using a tracking number, you can add it as the primary phone number in your Business Profile and then include your main business line as the “Additional Phone” number. This signals to Google that your actual number still exists while allowing you to track calls.
• Analyzing Call Data for ROI: Third-party call tracking tools offer a wealth of data that goes far beyond simple call counts. We can analyze:
  • Call Duration: Distinguish between quick, irrelevant calls and longer, high-intent conversations.
  • Caller Location: Understand where your valuable callers are coming from.
  • Time and Day: Identify peak calling hours and days. Studies show businesses often get more than 100 calls monthly from GMB listings, and call volume grew 22% between 2017 and 2018. Analyzing when these calls come in helps optimize staffing and marketing efforts.
  • Call Recordings: Listen to calls for quality assurance, staff training, and to understand customer needs.
  • Conversion Outcomes: Integrate with your CRM to track which calls turn into actual sales or appointments. This helps tie marketing efforts directly to revenue.
• Focusing on High-Quality Leads: Phone calls represent your highest-converting leads. 84% of marketers say phone calls deliver higher conversion rates and bigger order values compared to other forms of customer interaction. By analyzing call data, we can optimize our Google Business Profile and other marketing channels to attract more of these valuable, ready-to-convert callers. This might involve refining our service descriptions, optimizing our hours, or even running targeted call-only ads in Google Ads.

Frequently Asked Questions about Google Spam Calls

We often hear similar questions from business owners in Florida regarding unwanted calls. Here are some of the most common ones:

Will Google ever ask for payment to rank my business?

No. Google will never ask for payment information over the phone or guarantee special placement in search results for a fee. Any call demanding money for rankings is a scam. Legitimate ranking improvements come from comprehensive SEO strategies, not from paying a third party claiming to represent Google.

How can I stop all automated calls from Google?

You can opt out of most automated calls by telling the system during the call (e.g., “Please remove my business from your list.”) or by changing the settings in your Business Profile. Go to your Business Profile, select “More,” then “Business Profile settings,” then “Advanced settings,” and turn off “Google automated calls and text messages.” However, Google may still make manual calls to verify critical business information, even if you’ve opted out of automated ones.

Does reporting scam calls actually do anything?

Yes. Reporting calls to the FTC, FCC, and Google helps them build cases against fraudulent companies. While it may not stop every call immediately, it contributes to a larger effort to combat these scams. Each report helps agencies identify patterns, track down perpetrators, and potentially take legal action, making the digital environment safer for everyone.

Conclusion: Take Control of Your Business Calls

The world of Google My Business calls can feel like a minefield, with legitimate opportunities mixed with frustrating scams. But as we’ve explored, with the right knowledge and tools, we can steer this landscape effectively.

Here are the key takeaways:

• Be Vigilant: Always be skeptical of unsolicited calls claiming to be from Google, especially those demanding payment or threatening your listing. Trust your gut.
• Report Suspicious Activity: Don’t just hang up; take a few minutes to report scam calls to the FTC, FCC, and Google. Your report helps protect other businesses.
• Focus on Quality Leads: Understand the immense value of legitimate Google My Business calls. These are often your highest-intent leads, ready to convert.
• Accept Modern Tracking: With Google’s native call history disappearing, leverage third-party call tracking solutions to gain invaluable insights into your phone leads, optimize your marketing, and truly measure your ROI.

At BullsEye Internet Marketing, we specialize in helping businesses like yours attract high-quality local leads. We understand the nuances of Google Business Profiles, call tracking, and conversion optimization. With no long-term contracts and a commitment to working with only one client per industry per geographic area, we ensure your business has a competitive advantage in attracting those valuable calls.

Ready to transform your phone into a revenue-generating machine and filter out the noise? Learn how to generate more high-quality local leads with Pay Per Call ads.